My attention was grabbed this morning by a commentary that appeared in the New York Daily News last week entitled “De Blasio vs. Great Public Schools” by Jenny Sedlis and Derrell Bradford, who are both associated with Success Academy Public Charter Schools. In their piece they argue that Mayor de Blasio’s legacy of overseeing the city’s schools will be that there are many parents wanting quality seats for their children who cannot obtain them due to a capacity shortage. They write:
“When we look back decades from now on Mayor de Blasio’s tenure running New York City schools, one theme will emerge: There are way more children and families who want great schools than there are great schools for them.
More than a million kids are fighting for a number of great schools that they can’t all fit into. There’s no excellent school -district or charter- that doesn’t have a waiting list. Stuyvesant, Beacon, Success Academies: All these schools have more kids who want to get in than can.”
The article goes on to accuse Mr. de Blasio of poor treatment of Eva Moskowitz, the founder and chief executive officer of Success Academy.
While we do not have a mayor here in D.C. who is actively opposing a dynamic school leader, we do have the same problem with a lack of space in the city’s leading charter schools. For the school term that just started there is a reported 11, 317-student wait list for admission to charters. We have talked about this topic before, but just to point out a few of the greatest in-demand schools, they include Creative Minds International PCS with 1,574 students seeking admission; D.C. Bilingual PCS with 1,292 students on the wait list; Elsie Whitlow Stokes Community Freedom PCS – Brookland Campus with 1,827 pupils on the wait list, and Inspired Teaching Demonstration PCS with 1,071 kids trying to get in. The list literally does go on and on.
So I’m sitting at my desk wondering if decades from now this will be the legacy of Scott Pearson as executive director of the Public Charter School Board. Many people have spoken about the strengthening of school accountability under Mr. Pearson. Almost all of the lowest performing Tier 3 schools have been closed. Others have mentioned the significant professional improvement in the operation of the board through more standardized policies, procedures, and practices. Charter authorizers across the country look at the PCSB’s Performance Management Framework as the gold standard for the manner in which charters should be benchmarked against each other. All of these accomplishments are to be commended.
But what about the tremendous frustration that parents in this town face every year when they enter the My DC school lottery? They literally want to pull their hair out because they cannot get their children into the school of their choice. I really don’t understand why these people stay here as residents.
So what is Mr. Pearson doing about this issue? Well, the board is allowing some schools to replicate and increase their enrollment caps. But as you can see the demand is so much higher than the supply. What about making it easier for schools to grow? How about figuring out how to provide them with buildings? Has he looked into simplifying the application process for new schools and providing some incentives for groups to submit them?
It is fantastic to be known as the group that developed one of the strongest charter school portfolios in the nation. But if kids cannot get access to them, then what good have you really done?